BlogOn Writing

Managing Expectations as a New Writer

Managing expectations as a new writer means treating publication as a long, uneven process, not a vending machine you kick once the manuscript is done. Self-publishing can put a book on sale this week, but it will not, by itself, put that book in front of readers. Querying an agent or a large publisher can take months, often ends in a polite no — or a silence that means the same thing — and even a yes is the start of more waiting. The writing is still worth doing. The story you tell yourself about publication day is what needs a trim.

What follows is the unglamorous version of the work, told with a few invented colleagues who have already made the mistakes you are considering. None of them is based on a real person, and I am leaving my own books out of it.

The montage in your head

In the movie version, you type the last sentence, a choir comes in from somewhere off camera, and by lunch an agent has called, a publisher has scheduled a book tour, and a streaming service has optioned the series. You practice your modest face in the bathroom mirror. You draft a resignation letter, just in case.

In the weekday version, you hit save, notice that the file is called “Novel_FINAL_final2_USE_THIS.docx”, and then have to choose a path. Both paths are real. Neither one is a montage. A quiet week after “The End” is not evidence that the work was a waste. It is the ordinary pause before the next job starts.

If you self-publish

You can, in fact, upload a book tonight. That part is almost offensively easy, which is how it tricks people.

Picture Pam, who hits publish at 11:47 p.m. on a Tuesday and then sits in the glow of the sales dashboard as if it were a heart monitor. By morning she has three sales. Two are her, because she wanted to “test the buy button” on two devices and forgot she would be charged. The third is her mother, who would like a refund, because the eBook does not work on the toaster. Pam refreshes the page anyway. The page is very calm.

A higher royalty rate will not fix a book nobody can find. On Amazon’s Kindle Direct Publishing, eBook royalties are typically 35 percent or 70 percent of the list price, and the 70 percent option comes with price and territory rules, plus a delivery-cost deduction. Those are the published rates, not a sales forecast. Seventy percent of zero is a very tidy number.

The catalog is crowded. Bowker’s figures, as reported by Publishers Weekly, put U.S. self-published ISBN titles at more than 3.5 million in 2025, against 642,242 traditionally published titles that year. Your book is in there somewhere, between a sourdough memoir and a travel guide to a planet that does not exist. Listing the file is the short errand. Finding readers is the work.

Money is uneven, and it is usually smaller than the daydream. In the Authors Guild’s 2023 survey of 5,699 published authors, median book income for 2022 was $2,000 for all respondents, $10,000 for full-time authors, and $12,800 for full-time self-published authors. That is a picture of writers who answered a survey, not a forecast for your first week. Still, a published book is not, by itself, a salary.

You are also the publisher. That means editing, a cover that does not look like a clip-art hostage situation, metadata a human could search for, and a plan for telling people the book exists. If you are also the only editor, you have a fool for a client. Fresh eyes catch the typo your brain keeps correcting. I have a post on the stories self-published authors tell themselves.

Celebrate the true small thing: a sale to someone who does not share your last name. Then get back to the next chapter. The dashboard will not write it for you.

If you query an agent

An agent is not a prize for finishing a draft. An agent is a businessperson who makes a living by selling books they believe they can sell.

Now picture Barney, who pastes “Dear Agent” into forty emails in an afternoon and attaches a 180,000-word file named, with a straight face, “FINAL_final2_USE_THIS.docx.” The guidelines asked for a one-page query and the first ten pages. Barney follows up on Thursday. The queries went out on Tuesday. He takes the silence personally, which is impressive, because most of those inboxes have not even been opened.

Many agents take weeks or months to answer a query, when they answer at all. Some will tell you, plainly, that no answer after their stated window is a no. The best clock is the one on that agent’s own guidelines. Read them. If they want five pages, do not send the saga, the family tree, and a playlist. If they are closed, they are closed. Querying a closed agent is not persistence. It is leaving a casserole on a locked porch.

A request for pages is a good day. Take the good day. It is not a contract. An offer of representation is a better day. It is still not a book deal. The agent then has to take the book out to editors, who have to say yes inside a house that has its own lists, its own math, and its own crowded calendar. That can take more months. It can also end in a round of very polite declines. Those declines are the ordinary weather of this path, not a secret message that you should quit.

While you wait, write the next thing. A watched inbox boils nothing. If you are going to submit, research the people you are submitting to.

If a big publisher, or any traditional house, says yes

First, congratulations. Really. Then please practice, in the mirror if you have to, the sentence, “There is no movie.” Your uncle will ask. He will ask again at Thanksgiving.

A traditional book deal usually means an advance against royalties, paid in pieces, not a salary and not extra money on top of the book’s earnings. In a 2024 Poets & Writers guide, Lincoln Michel notes that agents generally describe a common debut advance as falling between $5,000 and $50,000, with plenty of deals above and below that range. The advance is typically yours if you fulfill the contract, even if the book sells poorly; it is not a loan you repay for a quiet season. You also, typically, do not see further royalty checks until the book earns that advance back. Michel is blunt about the next part: most books do not earn out, and for many authors the advance is the only money they will see directly from that title.

The royalty percentages are real, and they are not a treasure map. In that same guide, standard rates at the major New York houses are described as about 10 percent of the hardcover cover price, often with later steps up, about 7.5 percent on trade paperback, and commonly 25 percent of net receipts on ebooks. Payments tend to arrive on the publisher’s schedule, not yours.

The book itself may take a year or more, after the deal, to appear on a shelf. You will still be asked to help sell it. A publisher can design a cover, get the book into the machinery of distribution, and do work you cannot do from a laptop. It is not a silent partner that mails you a yacht and a tour bus.

A deal is still a deal worth taking seriously. Go into it with your eyes open, someone who can read the paperwork, and a life that does not depend on the first check arriving next Friday.

What a realistic week looks like

You write. You revise. You send work out, or you upload it, or you do both at different times for different projects. You wait, which is a skill, and you start the next thing, which is a better one. Keep the day job until the writing actually pays the bills, a point I have made before in Things to Consider Before Starting a Career as a Writer, because heat, rent, and groceries are unmoved by your sales ranking.

The wins worth keeping are the true ones. A stranger finishes the book. An agent asks for pages. A scene finally works. You do not need a choir for those. You need a chair with your butt in it, a keyboard, and a slightly less glamorous story about what happens after “The End.”

Where to go next on this site

If you are weighing self-publishing, start with 5 Lies Self Published Authors Tell. If you are still deciding whether writing should be your only job, see Things to Consider Before Starting a Career as a Writer. And if you are getting ready to submit, Researching Publishers Before Submitting will save you some casserole-on-a-locked-porch moments.